Everyone loves a good rant. This week's Thread of the Week got off to a rousing start with a rant on link buying, and went to three pages
in less than four hours. It's still growing. Stop buy and join the discussion!
This whole "buying links is bad" thing is really irritating (rant)
CommonDavid
For two reasons:
1. As a site/business owner, why in the heck wouldn't you want to buy links to get more traffic to your site. Why is it ok to buy traffic from Google Adwords, but not from a site selling link spots? This is a very slippery slope Google is creating by blatantly saying you'll get penalized for obvious link buys...
2. They're thinking is totally backwards on the subject. Their reasoning is based on the idea that "anyone can just go out and buy links", but what idiot goes out and buys links for stupid, crappy sites that don't give the end user the experience they want (there are tons and they go broke quick mind you)? If you as a business/ site owner feels that your site is good enough to spend thousands of dollars in buying links, then isn't that an indication that your site is WORTH BUYING these links for? I mean seriously, either you're:
a. not going to make any money from your paid links and then they'll come down (which in a perfect world would bring your natural listings down),
b. you'll make money from the paid links and keep them up, showing that the site is actually GOOD!
or
c. you have a bad site and have ridiculously deep pockets or just don't care about losing money, (but this option is the most unlikely out of the three).
The fact of the matter is that if you're willing to PAY MONEY FOR LINKS then you've probably got a site that's worth it. If anything is an indicator (besides user reviews or some other quantifiable user measure) of whether a site is worth getting natural Google listings, then MONEY SPENT on marketing and links is!
And don't even get me started on the whole "moral" issue either, that's a whole other thread!
/rant
-mj-
There are 2 main reasons to buy links:
Traffic and Ranking
Google has nothing against buying links for traffic. Add nofollow and you are fine.
Google has something against buying links for ranking. Often the links are not relevant to the sites topic thus useless for the visitor. They simply exist to pass linkjuice and thats what Google does not want.
If you live from selling links from your site add to paid links a nofollow tag and you can still make your money.
ClickyB
My own opinion is that it's a good thing.
In a way it's sad that Google started this whole "link-mania" thing; now I can only see two options for them:
1. Change they're fundamental principle about links=votes and look for other ways to rank sites.
2. Devalue paid and spam links.
Otherwise he who has the biggest budget/most time to spam gets the #1 spot irrespective of the quality of his site.
You said "you'll make money from the paid links and keep them up,
showing that the site is actually GOOD"... I do not agree with that;
just because a site sells product/makes money doesn't mean it's
the best site in its field.
You also said "The fact of the matter is that if you're willing
to PAY MONEY FOR LINKS then you've probably got a site that is worth
it" Worth it to you yes... Google is trying to find which sites
are most worth it to the surfer not the site owner.
Posts from this thread may have been abridged or removed. Forum members are responsible for the content of these posts.
Read the full thread. |